America’s best sports cities ranking released this week placed Pittsburgh in a surprising second spot, trailing New York by a narrow margin.
Fans drive the ranking.
Pittsburgh outscores larger markets
The CivicScience/SBJ Sports Consumer Insights survey asked respondents to name the top sports city in the United States. New York captured 20 percent of the vote, while Pittsburgh earned 16 percent, edging out Los Angeles and Chicago, each at 13 percent, and Boston at 10 percent.
Related: RBC Canucks partnership aims to boost fan value
Fan loyalty outweighs championship counts
Championships alone do not explain Pittsburgh’s standing. The Steelers have not won a Super Bowl since 2009, and the Penguins’ last Stanley Cup arrived in 2017. Yet the three major‑league teams together have logged 298 seasons of play in the city.
Long‑time Steelers fans have kept the stadium full since 1972, a streak that rivals any in the league. The Penguins maintained a sell‑out run of 633 games before the COVID‑19 pandemic broke it in fall 2021.
Beyond pro teams: a broader sports ecosystem
From 2026 through 2028, Pittsburgh will host eight NCAA postseason events across five sports, the most of any U.S. city for that period. Those events, combined with youth leagues and amateur competitions, help fill venues during the off‑season.
Related: Armato signs AJ Dybantsa 34 years after Shaq
Iconic venues amplify the city’s profile
Steelers games are often associated with sea‑of‑Terrible‑Towel images that appear on national broadcasts. Likewise, PNC Park’s downtown backdrop has become a staple of baseball coverage, showcasing the city’s skyline to viewers who may never travel there.
Industry view: market size versus civic pride
Sports Business Journal placed Pittsburgh at No. 32 on its 2026 Best Sports Business Cities list, a placement that aligns with the new survey’s findings. Analyst Samantha Reed of the outlet said the data suggests “civic identity and fan intensity can outweigh market size when people think about great sports cities.”
The perspective echoes the survey’s broader question: Are passionate fans and a cohesive sports culture more decisive than the sheer size of a media market?
Related: SBJ releases Jersey and Helmet Sponsor Directory
Local reactions and future outlook
Jerad Bachar, president and CEO of Visit Pittsburgh, said the ranking validates the city’s long‑standing reputation. “Our sports culture far exceeds its size,” he remarked, adding that the combination of professional teams, collegiate athletics, and event tourism creates a resilient ecosystem.
Looking ahead, planners aim to leverage the momentum by expanding facilities and promoting youth participation. The challenge will be maintaining venue use during off-season periods while keeping the community engaged.
For now, Pittsburgh’s surprising second-place finish highlights how a city’s collective enthusiasm can shape its national standing, even when recent championship banners are few.